Ok...I don't even want to bite on that one but I have a couple things to say.
I did get stronger and did climb "better" than I did before on every program I have done. I understand training protocol because of my time as a elite road cyclist. I followed the plans which were specifically designed for me. my schedule and my goals. I just wasn't motivated and it wasnt that fun for me. Climbing 13a was cool...but it was just a number at that point...not a great line.
I am now climbing very well simply by working problems..learning moves and campusing every now and then. Following my stopwatch and some training cards sucked the fun out of it. It got me into the 12's but climbing by feel has gotten me well into the 13's..and much more quickly/without injury.
Climbing is much more well rounded now.
Please. Climb the way that is most fun for you. Wear the shoes that fit your feet the best. Do static moves if it works better for you.
Climbing is what you make it. Not what people tell you it should be.
Unless you are an aid climber. Then it is all about getting lost in the dark and rapelling. Thats it.

