by JP » Thu Nov 20, 2008 11:39 am
The End of Faith by Sam Harris
Entertaining though a bit scattergun style book ranting against religious thought in general, and islamic movement in particular. Solid arguments last about half way to the book before he tries to offer some solutions.
His characterisation of islamic societies was misinformed and ignorrant - maybe deliberately, but i find it hard to trust a book characterising islamic countries from pakistan to iran without even mentioning the conflicts they have with progressive secular movements internally. Instead he just talks about some military solution which should take out advanced weaponry in the hands of any religious islamist leader. Having read about womens groups, student groups, unions and secular political parties (like secular non sectarian communist party polling 20% in some areas of iraq for instance) its clear that you cant just paint a whole country with the same brush. But Harris doesnt make a beep about that.
Otherwise entertaining easy to read book.
Rousseau's Dog: Two Great Thinkers at War in the Age of Enlightenment
Boring book unless you like to read about 18th century upper class squabbles.
Fateful Triangle: The United States, Israel, and the Palestinians by Noam Chomsky
This massive tome gives painfully detailed account of the history of the state of Israel and increasing in detail of evidence towards the 80s and especially the brutal lebanon invasion in 82. the focus and running theme of this book is the unblinkering and unquestioning financial, military, political and moral support of the US to the state of israel.
Triangle doesnt really fairly describe the relationship between the worlds only superpower, worlds 4th biggest military power and bunch of folk chased from their and without any recognised political representation (at the time of writing the book, 80s).
Chomsky being Chomsky, there is usually about 50 pages more evidence per argument than is needed to convince anyone, so this book works the best for those really deeply, interested in the situation, as a reference book for studies, articles and so on. As a bedside book you have to start skimming it pretty soon, or suffer some kind of mental breakdown.